Insights

HIPAA Compliant ChatGPT vs Claude for Healthcare

Both OpenAI and Anthropic offer business associate agreements, but each covers specific products and configurations. A side by side look for healthcare leaders.

AI & Governance
AI & Governance8 min readNovember 16, 2026Selah Digital Team
Share

Start with the agreement, not the model

Healthcare leaders often ask which assistant is HIPAA compliant. Neither is, on its own. What matters is whether the vendor will sign a business associate agreement for the product you plan to use, and whether you configure and govern it the way that agreement requires. Both OpenAI and Anthropic now publish detailed lists of what their BAAs cover.

Everything below reflects the vendors' public documentation as of November 2026. These lists change, so check the current versions before you decide.

OpenAI and ChatGPT

OpenAI's help center lists HIPAA eligible products available with a BAA. These include ChatGPT for Healthcare, ChatGPT Enterprise with a Regulated Workspace, ChatGPT for Clinicians and the API with what OpenAI calls Modified Retention. OpenAI states that it does not offer a BAA for ChatGPT Business, and consumer plans are not eligible.

For the API, OpenAI describes eligibility as requiring an executed BAA and, unless it specifies otherwise, provisioning for Modified Retention. It publishes a list of eligible endpoints. Its HIPAA guide also places responsibilities on the customer, such as configuring single sign on, securing devices and not creating accounts directly for patients.

Anthropic and Claude

Anthropic offers a BAA for its HIPAA ready services, which include a HIPAA ready API organization and HIPAA ready Claude Enterprise plans. On Enterprise, an organization owner activates HIPAA settings and accepts the BAA, and covered features are listed in Anthropic's help center. Third party connectors, some beta features and cloud based coding sessions are listed as not covered.

Claude is also offered through cloud platforms such as Amazon Bedrock, where the cloud provider's BAA and eligible services list apply instead.

How to compare them for your organization

Look at four things. First, which product your staff will actually use: a chat workspace, an API inside your own application, or a model through your cloud provider. Second, whether that exact product and plan is on the vendor's eligible list. Third, what configuration the vendor requires, such as retention settings or disabled features. Fourth, how the product fits your identity, logging and data loss prevention tools.

Beyond compliance, test both with your own scenarios. Ask clinicians and operations staff to try realistic tasks with de-identified examples, and compare accuracy, tone and how each handles questions it should not answer.

Our view

Many organizations will end up with more than one model, used for different jobs. The governance work is the same either way: a signed BAA, an eligible configuration, minimum necessary data, access control, logging and staff training.

Selah Digital is an Anthropic partner, a certified Salesforce partner and a registered AWS partner, and we are SOC 2 Type 2 certified (2025 report). We help healthcare teams make this choice and put the safeguards in place. Final decisions on HIPAA compliance belong with your privacy officer and counsel.

Ready to start?

Talk with the people who will do the work.

From the first conversation to go live, you work with our delivery team. No account-manager handoff, and no surprises.